Gangs of Sherwood Review – Why Does It Have Mixed Reviews on Steam?

Appeal Studios' Gangs of Sherwood is an intriguing action-adventure game that offers a unique take on the legendary Robin Hood saga. The game is set in a world combining science fiction and steam-punk elements, bringing a fresh perspective to the classic story. 

Gangs of Sherwood is a game that’s been stirring up quite a mix of reviews on Steam. You’ve probably seen the chatter – some players love it, some are scratching their heads, and others are just puzzled. What’s going on with Gangs of Sherwood? Let’s unravel this mystery together and find out why this game is like a rollercoaster ride of reviews!

A Creative Twist on a Classic Tale

The game boasts a unique “Sci-Fi fantasy Robin Hood” theme that incorporates airships, energy-powered longbows, and an assortment of advanced gadgets. However, some have criticized this fresh setting for prioritizing novelty over a gripping story. Despite its visually stunning environment, the plot is considered unremarkable and lacking in depth.

Critics have also noted the lack of character development for the game’s cast, including Robin Hood, resulting in a narrative that feels empty and uninteresting.

First off, Gangs of Sherwood isn’t your typical run-of-the-mill game. It takes the classic Robin Hood legend and spins it into a modern-day gang setting. Picture Robin Hood with a leather jacket and a smartphone – that’s the kind of vibe we’re talking about! This creative twist is a double-edged sword. 

While it’s fresh and exciting for some, others find it a bit too far from the traditional tale they love. It’s like putting pineapple on pizza – some think it’s a match made in heaven, others… not so much.

Gangs of Sherwood Lawod ss 1 1
Gangs of Sherwood Review - Why Does It Have Mixed Reviews on Steam? 5

Gameplay: Innovative or Overcomplicated?

The gameplay of Gangs of Sherwood is another talking point. The developers tried to blend strategy, action, and role-playing elements into one. 

When you play, you get to fight enemies using cool moves, just like in the “Devil May Cry” series. One of the playable characters, Robin, can do awesome things with his bow and arrow. You can learn to do all sorts of tricks like juggling your enemies with arrows, using magical powers, and other cool moves as you progress through the game.

Imagine juggling while riding a unicycle – that’s how complex it can get! For gamers who love a challenge, this is a feast. But for those who prefer a more straightforward experience, it’s like trying to solve a Rubik’s Cube blindfolded. This mixture of genres has left players divided. Some applaud the innovation, while others long for simplicity.

You also get to play as different characters like Robin, Marian, Little John, and Friar Tuck, each with their own special abilities. This makes the game more interesting because you can try different strategies with each character. You can even replay stages to try new things and see what works best for you.

Gangs of Sherwood Lawod ss 2 1
Gangs of Sherwood Review - Why Does It Have Mixed Reviews on Steam? 6

The Graphics: A Divided Opinion

Let’s talk visuals. Gangs of Sherwood sports a unique art style that’s not everyone’s cup of tea. It’s a mix of gritty realism and comic-book flair. Some players find it visually stunning, like walking into an art gallery. Others feel it’s a bit too out there, like wearing socks with sandals – unconventional and a bit jarring. This split in opinion adds another layer to the mixed reviews.

But I must say that Gangs of Sherwood definitely leverages the power of Unreal Engine 4 to create visually stunning environments despite its technical limitations. 

The game’s atmosphere is significantly enhanced by the lighting and post-processing. However, players have reported various bugs and glitches, such as issues with the character design, particularly Robin’s, which is perceived as lackluster compared to other characters. Furthermore, occasional crashes and AI problems suggest that the game needs further development and polishing.

Gangs of Sherwood Lawod ss 4 1
Gangs of Sherwood Review - Why Does It Have Mixed Reviews on Steam? 7

The Soundtrack: Hit or Miss

Music in games can be a powerful tool, and Gangs of Sherwood tried to capitalize on this. The soundtrack is an eclectic mix, blending medieval tunes with modern beats. For some, this fusion is music to their ears, a delightful blend of old and new. But for others, it’s like listening to a radio that can’t decide on a station. The soundtrack, while aiming to be innovative, ended up dividing players’ opinions further.

Community and Support

Gangs of Sherwood community is a passionate group of players that has been a shining light. Whether they love or have critiques about the game, their feedback has been invaluable. The game’s forums are buzzing with lively discussions, tips, and shared experiences. It’s like a big family dinner where everyone’s talking over each other but still having a great time. This community aspect is definitely a high point for Gangs of Sherwood.

Gangs of Sherwood Lawod ss 5 1
Gangs of Sherwood Review - Why Does It Have Mixed Reviews on Steam? 8

Overall Experience

So, there you have it – a peek into the world of Gangs of Sherwood and the reasons behind its mixed reviews on Steam. Whether you’re a fan of the game or still on the fence, one thing’s for sure: Gangs of Sherwood isn’t afraid to be different. It’s a game that dares to stand out, for better or worse. And in the vast universe of gaming, that’s something worth talking about!


The game stands out in its imaginative portrayal of Robin Hood, responsive combat mechanics, and impressive action sequences. Additionally, the game’s versatility is enhanced by the inclusion of both solo and co-op modes, providing a variety of gameplay experiences.


However, some critics have pointed out flaws in the game’s mission structure, which can feel disjointed at times, as well as its limited exploration mechanics and an unengaging storyline. These elements detract from the game’s overall potential.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button